Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?

Re: An honest question: Why Gaza? (1981058)	Home · Maps · About

Home > OTChat

[ Post a New Response | Return to the Index ]

[1 2 3 4]

< Previous Page

Page 3 of 4

Next Page >

(1981503)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Sat Apr 27 16:39:45 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by 3-9 on Sat Apr 27 15:50:35 2024.* Jews have only been considered white since 1945.
Post a New Response

(1981504)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Sat Apr 27 16:40:22 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by AlM on Sat Apr 27 16:11:04 2024.* They don’t even know the latter exist. Or Mizrahi.
Post a New Response

(1981505)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by rkba* on Sat Apr 27 16:41:10 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sat Apr 27 16:39:45 2024.* White-adjacent, perhaps. definitely not White.
Post a New Response

(1981507)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by rkba* on Sat Apr 27 16:41:57 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sat Apr 27 11:15:14 2024.* perception is everything.
Post a New Response

(1981512)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Chicagomotorman* on Sat Apr 27 16:55:36 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sat Apr 27 16:36:19 2024.* We've met. You are White.
Post a New Response

(1981513)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Chicagomotorman* on Sat Apr 27 16:56:07 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sat Apr 27 16:39:45 2024.* By whom?
Post a New Response

(1981514)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Sat Apr 27 18:06:45 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Chicagomotorman on Sat Apr 27 16:55:36 2024.* Thanks.
Post a New Response

(1981515)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Sat Apr 27 18:07:03 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Chicagomotorman on Sat Apr 27 16:56:07 2024.* By other white people.
Post a New Response

(1981516)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Chicagomotorman* on Sat Apr 27 18:29:13 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sat Apr 27 18:06:45 2024.* Uh, you're welcome.
Post a New Response

(1981517)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Chicagomotorman* on Sat Apr 27 18:29:47 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sat Apr 27 18:07:03 2024.* Link or fink?
Post a New Response

(1981518)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by https://salaamallah.com/* on Sat Apr 27 18:54:28 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Chicagomotorman on Sat Apr 27 18:29:47 2024.* RAT FINK ?
Post a New Response

(1981519)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Sat Apr 27 19:08:44 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Chicagomotorman on Sat Apr 27 18:29:47 2024.* https://jewishcurrents.org/when-did-jews-become-white
Post a New Response

(1981520)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by chicagoMotorman* on Sat Apr 27 19:09:02 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by https://salaamallah.com/ on Sat Apr 27 18:54:28 2024.*
Post a New Response

(1981521)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by 3-9* on Sat Apr 27 19:21:18 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by rkba on Sat Apr 27 16:41:10 2024.* I agree. Closer to white, but definitely not white.
Post a New Response

(1981524)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by https://salaamallah.com/* on Sat Apr 27 19:28:33 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by chicagoMotorman on Sat Apr 27 19:09:02 2024.* NOT THE ONE I REMEMBER 1960S ok
Post a New Response

(1981531)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Jeff Rosen* on Sat Apr 27 21:57:23 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Thu Apr 25 12:32:48 2024.* Rim shot!
Post a New Response

(1981533)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Jeff Rosen* on Sat Apr 27 22:03:33 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by 3-9 on Fri Apr 26 02:20:45 2024.* They had plenty of farms, warehouses, and greenhouses when Israel withdrew in 2005 and left all the infrastructure. Gee, I wonder what happened to it all.
Post a New Response

(1981538)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Jeff Rosen* on Sat Apr 27 22:35:21 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by chicagoMotorman on Sat Apr 27 19:09:02 2024.*
Post a New Response

(1981560)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Avid Reader* on Sun Apr 28 09:52:18 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sat Apr 27 16:39:45 2024.* Jews have only been considered white since 1945. I'm pretty sure like many faiths, Jews com in just about all races.
Post a New Response

(1981561)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Sun Apr 28 11:24:06 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Avid Reader on Sun Apr 28 09:52:18 2024.* Jews come in one race, human.
Post a New Response

(1981569)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by 3-9* on Sun Apr 28 13:36:06 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Jeff Rosen on Sat Apr 27 22:03:33 2024.* The stuff from the Jewish settlers may have been more than enough for them, but for over 2 million Palestinians, likely not nearly enough. Though I agree the Palestinians kindly trashed what was left behind.
Post a New Response

(1981573)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Olog-hai* on Sun Apr 28 14:06:42 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by 3-9 on Sun Apr 28 13:36:06 2024.* Rubbish. Who do you think was feeding the 1.3 million "Palestinians" who were living in Gaza before 2005? The 9,000 Israelis who were evicted from their homes and businesses. Hamas trashed all of what was there and turned it towards their own uses, making the populace who voted for them into abject dependents.
Post a New Response

(1981575)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Sun Apr 28 14:35:20 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by 3-9 on Sun Apr 28 13:36:06 2024.* This is such bullshit, unless you believe Gaza ought to adopt North Korean-style autarky. Many countries are not self-sufficient when it comes to food and import their food. They know if they go to war they need to prepare accordingly, that Hamas didn't do so is on them. If there were a Palestinian genocide, and there most certainly is not, then Hamas is solely responsible. People who blame Israel for alleged Palestinian privation and death are no better than people who blamed the Allies for German and Japanese privation and death.
Post a New Response

(1981581)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by BILLBKLYN* on Sun Apr 28 15:38:01 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sat Apr 27 19:08:44 2024.* That was a good read! But why are we even having these conversations in 2024? Most of us here would have not been considered "white" at one point or another, but now we are.
Post a New Response

(1981595)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Sun Apr 28 18:31:34 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by BILLBKLYN on Sun Apr 28 15:38:01 2024.* It’s interesting how the different “races” came to be and how arbitrary they are. Although there is some merit to the racial categories, they’re not perfect.
Post a New Response

(1981601)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Train Dude* on Sun Apr 28 19:53:19 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by 3-9 on Sun Apr 28 13:36:06 2024.* "Kindly trashed"? What the hell does that even mean?
Post a New Response

(1981607)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by 3-9* on Sun Apr 28 22:42:12 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sun Apr 28 14:35:20 2024.* Well, then, the Israelis will have to make themselves clear. Are they only after Hamas, or are they trying to beat up all the Palestinians in Gaza? Because they're saying one thing but doing something else.
Post a New Response

(1981608)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Sun Apr 28 23:08:28 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by 3-9 on Sun Apr 28 22:42:12 2024.* They are saying one thing and doing the same thing. It’s anti-Israel propaganda that is lying about what Israel is doing.
Post a New Response

(1981609)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Olog-hai* on Mon Apr 29 01:13:19 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sat Apr 27 19:08:44 2024.* Breaking news, analysis, art, and culture from a progressive Jewish perspective … That shows up on a Google search for that website. And they're quoting Noel Ignatiev of all people, seriously?
Post a New Response

(1981610)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Olog-hai* on Mon Apr 29 01:13:39 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by BILLBKLYN on Sun Apr 28 15:38:01 2024.* No, it was a garbage read.
Post a New Response

(1981611)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Olog-hai* on Mon Apr 29 01:18:37 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Avid Reader on Sun Apr 28 09:52:18 2024.* Jews are an ethnicity. Judaism is a religion.
Post a New Response

(1981614)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by https://salaamallah.com/* on Mon Apr 29 04:30:59 2024, in response to An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by shiznit1987 on Mon Apr 22 18:49:40 2024.*
Post a New Response

(1981615)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by https://salaamallah.com/* on Mon Apr 29 04:31:46 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Olog-hai on Mon Apr 29 01:18:37 2024.* NO YOU ARE A RACE
Post a New Response

(1981619)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Mon Apr 29 10:23:07 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Olog-hai on Mon Apr 29 01:13:39 2024.* To you, maybe, but you're insane.
Post a New Response

(1981621)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by https://salaamallah.com/* on Mon Apr 29 11:18:28 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sat Apr 27 19:08:44 2024.* YOU ARE WHITE !!! YOU ARE
Post a New Response

(1981622)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Mon Apr 29 11:26:28 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by https://salaamallah.com/ on Mon Apr 29 11:18:28 2024.* Whatever you say.
Post a New Response

(1981623)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by https://salaamallah.com/* on Mon Apr 29 11:35:28 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Mon Apr 29 11:26:28 2024.* NO PIG TELL THE TRUTH THATS ALL
Post a New Response

(1981624)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Mon Apr 29 11:36:23 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by https://salaamallah.com/ on Mon Apr 29 11:35:28 2024.* You first.
Post a New Response

(1981625)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by AlM* on Mon Apr 29 11:43:14 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sun Apr 28 23:08:28 2024.* Israel is killing a lot of Gazans who are not part of Hamas. You can say they have no choice, but it is a fact that they are doing so.
Post a New Response

(1981626)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by AlM* on Mon Apr 29 11:43:24 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Sun Apr 28 23:08:28 2024.* Israel is killing a lot of Gazans who are not part of Hamas. You can say they have no choice, but it is a fact that they are doing so.
Post a New Response

(1981627)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by https://salaamallah.com/* on Mon Apr 29 11:46:45 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Mon Apr 29 11:36:23 2024.* YOU
Post a New Response

(1981635)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Mon Apr 29 13:29:01 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by AlM on Mon Apr 29 11:43:14 2024.* The US Army killed a lot of Germans who were not SS.
Post a New Response

(1981643)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Train Dude* on Mon Apr 29 15:25:21 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by AlM on Mon Apr 29 11:43:14 2024.* And so another statement borne out of ignorance from alm
Post a New Response

(1981646)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by chicagoMotorman* on Mon Apr 29 15:37:56 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by AlM on Mon Apr 29 11:43:14 2024.* So?
Post a New Response

(1981647)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by AlM* on Mon Apr 29 15:40:07 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Mon Apr 29 13:29:01 2024.* As I said, you can say that they have no choice.
Post a New Response

(1981653)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by 3-9* on Mon Apr 29 16:17:34 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Mon Apr 29 13:29:01 2024.* The US Army didn't have precision and guided weapons in WWII.
Post a New Response

(1981659)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Train Dude* on Mon Apr 29 17:51:06 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by 3-9 on Mon Apr 29 16:17:34 2024.* Astounding ignorance! The firebombing of Dresden and the nuking of Hiroshima were far more than the lack of precision guided weapons. They were meant to send dramatic messages to the civilian population and the waring governments that they support.
Post a New Response

(1981661)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Avid Reader* on Mon Apr 29 18:16:48 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by AlM on Mon Apr 29 11:43:24 2024.* War is HELL! Hamas opened the gates of HELL, and the innocent are getting burned.
Post a New Response

(1981664)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by Spider-Pig* on Mon Apr 29 18:32:49 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Train Dude on Mon Apr 29 17:51:06 2024.* And in any case the US did have precision weapons.
Post a New Response

(1981665)	view threaded
Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?
Posted by 3-9* on Mon Apr 29 18:50:56 2024, in response to Re: An honest question: Why Gaza?, posted by Spider-Pig on Mon Apr 29 18:32:49 2024.* Like what? And besides, the Geneva Conventions regarding mistreating civilians came after WWII.
Post a New Response

[1 2 3 4]
< Previous Page	Page 3 of 4	Next Page >

[ Return to the Message Index ]