Home · Maps · About

Home > SubChat
 

[ Read Responses | Post a New Response | Return to the Index ]
[ Next in Thread ]

 

view flat

Straphangers railing against bedraggled 7th Ave. station

Posted by Allan on Fri Jan 30 19:59:53 2009

edf40wrjww2msgDetail:detailStr
fiogf49gjkf0d
From the local paper "Chelsea Now" that I picked up while downtown earlier today.

The station in question is 14th St/7th Av.

http://www.chelseanow.com/cn_120/straphangers.html


"Straphangers railing against bedraggled 7th Ave. station

By Heather Murray

Gray stalactites of peeling paint hang down from the ceiling of the 14th St. subway station entrance at the northwest corner of Seventh Ave., while an inch of rainwater greets straphangers walking down the first set of stairs.

The deteriorating conditions at the station have been an issue that W. 15th St. resident Susanna Miller has complained about to friends and neighbors for as long as she can remember.

Now, the longtime resident is reaching out to elected officials, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority and community representatives in an effort to get the MTA to renovate the station.

While on the phone with a 311 operator to report an unrelated incident last summer, Miller decided she would also register her longstanding concerns about the peeling paint, cruddy ceilings and stairwell flooding at the heavily trafficked station. The Seventh Ave. station serves the Nos. 1, 2 and 3 lines north- and southbound, as well as connecting by tunnel to the Sixth Ave. station, which services the L, F and V lines as well as the PATH train to New Jersey.

A week after her call, Miller received a letter from an MTA representative indicating that the authority had referred her complaint to the Department of Subways for review and investigation.

She expected to hear back from the MTA soon after receiving that letter, but five months went by with no update. Then, after calling to the MTA in October “and getting nowhere,” Miller decided to start a petition calling for the station to be renovated.

“After living in this area for over 30 years, I decided that I was sick and tired of the way this subway station looked (especially the peeling paint and unsightly ceiling at the northwest corner),” she wrote in her petition,

Peter Schulze saw Miller’s petition posted in his co-op building at 161 W. 15th St. last fall and took it to a tenants’ meeting to get more signatures for the cause.

“I’ve been noticing the issues there for a long time,” said Schulze, who’s lived in the same building for 29 years and in Chelsea for 45 years. “For myself and my partner, each time we go up to Lincoln Center we notice the paint peeling from the ceiling and that the station looks just filthy. It’s in great need, minimally, of cleaning.” But considering the current economic circumstances and financial constraints facing the MTA, “I’m not having much hope that we’ll accomplish something,” he added.

Schulze also noted the stairwell flooding but figured that it is “probably unavoidable when we have heavy rains.” He claimed that renovations haven’t been performed at the station for at least as long as he has lived there, but he does recall the Nos. 1, 2 and 3 line stations receiving repairs soon after he moved in. “Fourteenth St. has been sadly neglected,” he said. “The fact that this very busy station was never addressed surprised me.”

Miller, who works as a real estate broker, cited the area’s ever-rising property values as reason enough to make improvements.

“We have multimillion-dollar apartments in the neighborhood,” she said, “and the subway stations don’t reflect the way the neighborhood is progressing.”

Stanley Bulbach, president of the W. 15th Street 200 Block Association, also agrees with Miller. He spoke of the “hyperdevelopment” taking place in the neighborhood and the reality that big projects planned at Pier 57 and St. Vincent’s Hospital nearby would put more strain on the subway system.

“There’s never any attention to the local infrastructure,” Bulbach said. “If they’re going to be building up St. Vincent’s, what about taking a look at the antiquated subway station here?”

He added that many neighbors have complained to him about limited handicapped access at the Seventh Ave. station, an issue also raised by Miller that could impact disabled users traveling to and from the hospital two blocks to the south.

Bulbach and other community members monitored the rehabilitation of the Eighth Ave. station at 14th St. in the ’90s. He felt that project “was only pushed through in the correct way after Community Boards 2 and 4 formed a 14th Street joint committee,” and that this now-defunct committee should be resurrected to work on the Seventh Ave. station and other issues of mutual concern.

Board 4’s Transportation Planning Committee agreed to write a resolution “indicating that the condition of the station does create a safety hazard, particularly because of the leaks,” said committee co-chairperson Jay Marcus. “It should be repaired immediately,” The committee recently discussed Miller’s petition at its Jan. 21 meeting.

As part of a plan that the MTA developed after the Americans with Disabilities Act was adopted in 1990, it promised to make 100 “key” stations—not including Seventh Ave.—handicapped accessible by 2020. Last summer, the MTA reached its 2010 pledge of making 67 stations accessible two years ahead of schedule.

Marcus said his committee would explore whether the Seventh Ave. station could make the cut as a station slated for renovation.

“They could also look at reopening the tunnel between Seventh and Eighth Avenue,” he added. It closed several years ago.

Miller has also contacted Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer’s office, which was able to negotiate with both boards to work jointly on the issue, said press secretary Carmen Boon. “Meanwhile, our office plans to send a letter to the MTA sometime soon to urge the authority to review the issues and correct them,” she added.

Fran Nesi, who’s on the board of directors for the Vermeer at 77 Seventh Ave. and is a block association member, thinks Miller is standing behind “a really important initiative” because “the subway station is so deplorable.” Nesi is supportive of “anything we can do as a neighborhood to get even some minimal rehab work done there, even just some painting and work on the walls and ceiling,” she added. “So many new buildings are going up here. It’s an amazing neighborhood, and the subway station is like a blot on the neighborhood.”

Nesi believes the station has been neglected by the MTA, and she hopes the petition will draw attention to problems that need fixing. “I realize this is a very tough time economically for the city, the state and the MTA,” she said. “And I realize we’re fighting an uphill battle. But at least we could get in the queue now.”

According to Jeremy Soffin, deputy director of media relations for the MTA, the Seventh Ave. station is already in the queue. He said the station has been identified as one that needs “component” work done, which will likely be completed during the next five-year capital projects cycle starting in January 2010, if the MTA receives enough funding from the state.

“We’ve made a shift in how we’re dealing with station renovations,” Soffin said. “The cost of renovating them has really soared.” He added that the MTA simply doesn’t have enough funding each five-year cycle to perform renovations at all of the stations in need of work.

The MTA is moving toward component work, which Soffin defined as projects that supplement the full renovation schedule. Rather than doing a full renovation of the Seventh Ave. station or other locations, the MTA “can come in and do a paint job or fix a crumbling staircase,” he said."



Responses

Post a New Response

Your Handle:

Your Password:

E-Mail Address:

Subject:

Message:



Before posting.. think twice!


[ Return to the Message Index ]